novelsite

Chapter 37 - The Hearing About Her Face

The courtroom was smaller than I expected.

I do not know why that surprised me.

Perhaps because the internet had made the harm feel enormous, and enormous things ought to require enormous rooms.

Instead, there were worn benches, fluorescent lights, and a clerk who asked us to keep the aisle clear.

The hearing concerned limited relief.

Use of Lulu’s image.

Disputed permissions.

Preservation of records.

Certain contact restrictions.

The financial claims would continue separately.

So would the investigations.

No one had promised that one morning could contain all of it.

Lulu did not attend.

She had asked whether the judge needed to see her.

Naomi said her interests could be represented without requiring that.

“Good,” Lulu replied. “My face has done enough work.”

I carried that sentence into court.

Celia sat at the opposite table.

Elise sat behind her lawyer.

Evelyn arrived last.

For a moment, she looked directly at me.

I expected anger.

Instead, she wore the expression she used when I was a teenager and she wanted other adults to believe she was being patient.

It still reached something old inside me.

I kept my eyes on the front.

Naomi presented the original authorization I had actually signed.

Limited excursion supervision.

Not publicity.

Not fundraising.

Not medical-information access for strangers.

Then she presented the disputed releases.

Same signature image.

Different purposes.

Different recipients.

The opposing attorneys disputed responsibility and emphasized that their clients had relied on materials supplied through family channels.

The judge asked a question.

“Where is the parent’s direct approval for this use?”

Paper moved.

Someone whispered.

No one produced an answer that satisfied the question.

Then came the hospital photograph.

I did not look at it on the screen.

I had seen my daughter in that bed.

I did not need to see her displayed again to understand what had been taken.

The inquiry into its source had identified a local assistance account that obtained the image after receiving the disputed authorization. The precise circumstances of its creation and transfer remained under review.

That did not give the defendants permission to keep using it.

Naomi made the distinction clearly.

The judge issued limited interim restrictions addressing the disputed image use and requiring preservation of relevant materials within the court’s authority.

No one was declared innocent.

No one was declared guilty of everything I believed.

But certain doors closed.

Certain uses stopped.

Certain files could no longer be casually deleted while everyone argued over what they meant.

Outside, Evelyn called my name.

Her attorney moved toward her immediately.

I stopped several feet away.

Not close enough for a private conversation.

Not far enough to pretend I had not heard.

“This has gone far enough,” she said.

For years, that sentence had meant I was expected to end the discomfort she helped create.

I looked at her.

“It went too far when Lulu asked for help and you left.”

Her mouth tightened.

“You’ll regret making this public.”

I did not answer.

Naomi guided us toward the exit.

In the parking lot, I realized my hands were steady.

Not because my mother had become harmless.

Because I had not tried to make her agree.

That was new.

At home, Lulu sat at the kitchen table with Maya, surrounded by cardboard and wiring.

I told her the practical result.

The image restrictions.

The records.

What remained unresolved.

She listened.

Then asked, “Do I have to be grateful to the judge?”

I smiled.

“You can be glad someone did their job.”

“Good.”

Maya looked up.

“Can we still borrow the big scissors?”

“Yes.”

“Even after the incident?”

I stared.

Lulu sighed.

“She means the cardboard lampshade.”

I looked toward the trash.

A mangled cylinder leaned against the bin.

“What happened?”

“Structural disagreement,” Maya said.

I laughed.

Later, Lulu found me folding laundry.

“Did Grandma say anything?”

“Yes.”

“Was it about me?”

“Mostly about what she thinks I should do.”

Lulu considered.

Then nodded.

“Same as always.”

I handed her a stack of shirts.

She took them.

May you like

For once, we let that be the end of the conversation.

***

Related Stories

Other posts