novelsite

Chapter 12 - Permission She Never Gave

Lulu stayed home that morning.

I called the school and used the words family matter because I could not bring myself to explain that my mother had turned my daughter’s medical emergency into a fundraising campaign.

Then I called work and traded my shift.

By ten o’clock, Naomi sat at our dining table with her laptop open.

My father occupied the chair farthest from Lulu.

He had explained that the previous fundraiser had been a country-club luncheon. Celia Rowan ran a small publicity and event-planning business. Evelyn had persuaded him to contribute eighteen thousand dollars toward what she called a travel-assistance initiative.

He had written the check.

He had not reviewed the accounts.

I had not decided which part made me angrier.

Naomi examined the website while Lulu sat beside me, twisting a hair tie around her wrist.

“Did anyone ask your permission to use this photograph?” Naomi asked me.

“No.”

“Did anyone ask yours?” she asked Lulu.

My daughter shook her head.

“Do you know who took it?”

I enlarged the image.

The angle was wrong for anything I had taken. It showed the side of the bed, the privacy curtain, the corner of a nurse’s station beyond the open doorway.

“My father might know,” I said.

He leaned forward.

Then he closed his eyes.

“Desiree sent me that photograph.”

The room went quiet.

“When?”

“The day Lulu was admitted. Before the ship came back.”

“How did she get it?”

“I don’t know.”

“Did you ask?”

He looked at me.

“No.”

Lulu stopped twisting the hair tie.

“She had a picture of me before she came back?”

“We don’t know how she received it,” Naomi said gently. “We’ll ask the people who can check.”

I appreciated that she did not let our fear become a fact just because it felt convincing.

She saved copies of the pages, donation descriptions, photographs, and organizer details. Then she opened a tab labeled FAMILY AUTHORIZATION.

A scanned document appeared.

My name sat at the bottom.

Holly Ferrante.

Beneath it was a signature that looked enough like mine to make my stomach turn.

The release supposedly gave Celia’s company permission to use Lulu’s name, image, and medical story in “educational and charitable outreach.”

“I didn’t sign that.”

Naomi looked at me.

“Have you ever signed anything for this company?”

“No.”

“Anything connected to the original luncheon?”

“No.”

My father shifted in his chair.

“I signed a donor acknowledgment.”

“That’s different,” Naomi said.

But she asked him to find it.

Lulu stared at the release.

“So they’re pretending you said yes.”

“Yes.”

“What happens if I say no?”

Naomi turned her laptop so my daughter could see it.

“Then your answer matters.”

For the first time that morning, Lulu’s shoulders loosened.

Naomi sent preservation demands and a notice disputing the release. She contacted the fundraising platform through its reporting process and prepared requests concerning the photograph’s source.

She also asked whether we wanted a public statement.

I looked at Lulu.

She surprised me.

“Not yet.”

“You don’t have to decide today,” I said.

“I know. I just don’t want everybody looking at the picture again.”

Naomi nodded.

“That’s a very reasonable concern.”

After she left, my father remained.

“I thought I was helping,” he said.

I stood at the sink, rinsing mugs that were already clean.

“Who?”

He did not answer immediately.

“Your mother said the program would help families like yours.”

“Families like mine, or the family she wanted people to think we were?”

“Holly—”

“Did you ever ask where the money went?”

“No.”

There was no anger in his answer. Just exhaustion.

I wanted to forgive him for being tired.

I also remembered how often I had been asked to forgive him for being quiet.

Behind us, Lulu spoke.

“Grandpa, did Grandma use me at the luncheon too?”

He turned toward her.

“There was a photograph in the program.”

“What photograph?”

“You at the beach. From the summer before.”

Lulu’s face went still.

“I told her not to post that.”

My father looked at me.

I looked at my daughter.

May you like

She had been saying no longer than either of us understood.

And the people who called themselves her family had simply been speaking louder.

Related Stories

Other posts