Chapter 32 - Her Birthday Without Her

Lydia’s birthday fell on a Saturday.
Marcus told me in advance.
He and the boys planned to visit the cemetery, then have lunch at a place she liked.
He asked whether I wanted dinner afterward.
I heard the care in the invitation.
A place for me that did not require entering every part of their grief.
“Yes,” I said.
Then, later, alone, I became unexpectedly upset.
Not because he was remembering his wife.
I respected that.
Because some frightened part of me still wanted love to come with proof that I could not be compared with another woman and found lacking.
The difference embarrassed me.
Lydia had not competed with me.
She was dead.
Yet I could feel old habits trying to place her in Courtney’s chair.
I called Rachel.
She listened without interrupting.
Then said, “You can have an ugly feeling without making it someone else’s assignment.”
I laughed weakly.
“Could you say that more gently?”
“Certainly. Have your ugly feeling, darling.”
I covered my face.
She waited.
Finally, I said, “I don’t want him to think I resent her.”
“Do you?”
“No.”
“Then tell him what you actually feel.”
I did.
Marcus listened in my kitchen while I stumbled through the explanation.
He did not rush to reassure me that I was prettier, easier, or better.
He would have lost something important if he had.
Instead, he said, “I can love you without ranking you against my wife.”
I looked at him.
“I know.”
“And you can need reassurance without pretending the comparison makes sense.”
I exhaled.
There it was.
Room for the feeling.
No obligation to obey it.
On Saturday, I spent the morning with Rachel.
We visited a pottery shop, bought mugs neither of us needed, and argued about whether I could keep a small citrus tree alive indoors.
Rachel believed the evidence was poor.
I bought the tree anyway.
That afternoon, Jared sent a photograph.
A ridiculous cake from years earlier.
Lydia had attempted to decorate it as a moving truck.
It looked like an injured refrigerator.
The message read:
Dad said you’d appreciate this.
I laughed.
Not because I had been invited to replace the memory.
Because I had been trusted to enjoy it.
At dinner, Marcus told me about the cemetery.
Only what he wanted to share.
Luke had brought the kitchen timer.
Jared had read a note he wrote after discovering the payments to Peter.
They had been angry.
Sad.
Quiet.
Then hungry.
They went to lunch.
I listened.
When he finished, I said, “I’m glad you went.”
He nodded.
Then asked about my day.
I told him about the citrus tree.
His expression became professionally concerned.
“The balcony light—”
“I have received enough criticism.”
He smiled.
We ate.
Later, he gave me a copy of a recipe.
Lydia’s handwriting.
A simple bread she used to make.
“Luke found several copies,” he said. “He thought you might want one because you bake.”
I looked at the page.
For a moment, I could not speak.
“Only if you want it,” Marcus added.
“I do.”
That night, I placed it beside the recipe from Dylan’s mother.
Two women.
Different histories.
Neither required erasure.
I stood in my kitchen looking at them.
For years, I thought freedom meant stripping the past from every room.
Now I wondered whether freedom might also mean choosing what could remain without giving it control.
The citrus tree sat by the window.
Outside, the lavender moved in the dark.
May you like
For once, nothing in the room felt like a rival.
***