Chapter 20 - The Painting in Chicago

Evening Reach was not missing.
It hung in a private collection in Chicago.
That was the first sentence Arthur said when I answered.
I sat down so abruptly the chair struck the wall.
“What?”
“The gallery has supplied transaction and collection records. They have been authenticated sufficiently for the current review. Further questions remain, but the original painting was collected before the shipment to Buckeye.”
I stared at the balcony door.
The lavender moved in the breeze.
For weeks, I had imagined a valuable object hidden in a warehouse, delivered to a house, or used as bait in another version of my marriage.
All that time, it had been hanging somewhere quiet.
“How long before?”
“Several months.”
“And Courtney knew?”
“The sale agreement bears her acknowledged signature. Her former husband’s counsel has supplied related correspondence.”
I closed my eyes.
That was the difference between suspicion and a wall of records.
A title.
A payment.
Collection arranged.
Delivery confirmed.
Then a later claim for the same original.
The framed item sent to Ohio appeared to have been the reproduction Judith described.
Its actual condition and whereabouts still mattered.
Buckeye could not escape responsibility for any real loss by pointing to a false valuation.
Marcus understood that.
So did his insurer.
But a damaged or misplaced reproduction was not an original worth one hundred eighty-six thousand dollars.
The numbers finally had to live beside the object.
A meeting followed.
I attended only for the portion concerning the alleged release and my supposed receipt of the painting.
Courtney sat across the table with her attorney.
For the first time since she came to my apartment, she looked less than perfectly arranged.
A loose strand of hair.
A blouse cuff folded unevenly.
Small things.
They did not delight me.
I had stopped needing her humiliation to prove my freedom.
Her attorney explained that descriptions might have been carried forward from prior inventory materials.
Arthur asked about the sale.
The correspondence.
The instruction to retain “original artwork.”
The valuation.
Courtney looked at the table.
Then she looked at me.
“This was never about you.”
I held her gaze.
“My name was on the release.”
“You inserted yourself into Marcus’s life.”
I almost laughed.
The astonishing elasticity of blame.
“I started dating a man months after my divorce. You claimed I received a painting that had already been delivered to someone else.”
Her attorney spoke.
Arthur answered.
The conversation returned to documents.
That was where it belonged.
Afterward, outside, I stood beneath a maple tree while Marcus finished with his counsel.
Courtney came out first.
She stopped several feet away.
For a moment, neither of us spoke.
Then she said, “Dylan never stopped talking about you in Florida.”
The old weapon.
Comparison.
A last little hook.
I looked at her.
“I’m not applying to win that week.”
She blinked.
“He was miserable.”
“That is between you and the man you invited.”
I turned away.
Not dramatically.
I simply had nothing else to contribute.
Marcus joined me a few minutes later.
He looked drained.
“There will still be a legitimate review of our handling.”
“I know.”
“Possible payment for the actual item and other established losses.”
“I know.”
He studied me.
“You’re allowed to be relieved.”
“I am.”
“Only relieved?”
I thought about it.
“No. Angry. Tired. Embarrassed that I ever let either of them make me feel small.”
Marcus nodded.
Then he said, “Would you like lunch?”
Such a practical question.
No promise that he would protect me from every future cruelty.
No declaration that I was finally safe because the records were clear.
Lunch.
A chair.
Someone willing to sit beside the mixed feelings instead of sorting them into a prettier ending.
“Yes,” I said.
We went to a little restaurant with uneven tables and terrible parking.
I ordered something I wanted.
May you like
For once, that was the only decision I had to defend.
***