Chapter 16 - Aunt Judith

Courtney’s aunt arrived at Marcus’s office carrying a canvas handbag and wearing shoes no one would mistake for resort footwear.
Her name was Judith Pierce.
She was seventy-one, blunt, and visibly unimpressed by the arrangement of chairs in the conference room.
“Why is everyone sitting as if we’re about to negotiate a hostage exchange?”
Marcus’s attorney looked startled.
Judith pulled out a chair herself.
“Never mind. I assume the painting is the hostage.”
I liked her immediately.
That made me cautious.
Liking someone had never been proof.
Arthur sat beside me.
Marcus attended with company counsel.
Judith had her own lawyer on the call.
She had agreed to meet after receiving formal questions concerning the cottage and the artwork displayed there.
The cottage was hers.
Courtney had been permitted to use it.
Not as an owner.
Not indefinitely.
And not as a warehouse for property Judith could not identify.
“What did Courtney tell you?” Judith asked me.
“That she needed support after a devastating divorce.”
Judith looked down.
Then sighed.
“Some of that may have felt true to her.”
A careful answer.
I respected it more than a gleeful demolition.
“The financial story is disputed,” she continued. “Her former husband has records. So do I. I’m not here to try their divorce in this room.”
She opened her handbag.
“I’m here because my niece has used my house as evidence of a life she wanted other people to finance.”
The sentence landed hard.
Marcus’s attorney asked about Evening Reach.
Judith examined the photograph.
“Yes. That hung above the sofa.”
“Did Courtney own it?”
“She acquired it during her marriage. I understood it was later sold.”
“When?”
Judith referred to her papers.
Before the shipment to Ohio.
I sat straighter.
“Was the painting removed from the cottage?”
“Not immediately.”
“Why?”
“The buyer agreed to delayed collection.”
“Then what was transported?”
“That is an excellent question.”
Judith took out another photograph.
A decorator’s installation record.
The original painting had been replaced with a high-quality reproduction in a similar frame.
I stared.
“So the picture from Key West—”
“May show the reproduction,” Arthur said.
Not a perfect solution.
A new distinction.
I had nearly treated the vacation photograph as the answer because I wanted it to be.
Now the truth required more work.
Judith looked at me.
“Disappointing?”
“A little.”
“Usually is.”
I smiled despite myself.
She supplied the gallery’s name and authorized her lawyer to coordinate the records she controlled.
Then she turned toward Marcus.
“Did your people receive a framed item?”
“Yes.”
“Did anyone open the wrapping and establish what it was?”
Marcus did not look away.
“We do not have a reliable record establishing that.”
Judith nodded.
“Then you have a problem even if my niece has a larger one.”
No one argued.
Afterward, she asked whether I would walk downstairs with her.
Arthur remained within sight.
Judith leaned against the elevator wall.
“I knew Dylan was married.”
I looked at her.
“He told me you didn’t enjoy travel.”
The words were so familiar I almost laughed.
“What did you say?”
“That a wife’s preference was not the only reason a married man should reconsider sharing a cottage with an old girlfriend.”
“Did he listen?”
“He smiled.”
Of course he did.
Judith looked tired.
“I should have asked more.”
“Yes.”
She nodded.
No injured surprise.
No insistence that I reassure her.
At the lobby doors, she touched my arm lightly, then withdrew it as if remembering she had not asked permission.
“For what it’s worth, you were never the dull person in that story.”
I looked toward the street.
For years, I would have treasured that sentence as proof.
Now it felt kind.
Only kind.
That was enough.
At home, I took the lavender plants out of their plastic pots.
Marcus joined me on the balcony.
We worked without talking for several minutes.
Then I said, “Your customer may have shipped a reproduction.”
He nodded.
“And my company may have documented it badly.”
“Yes.”
Both facts could exist.
May you like
Neither required me to surrender the other.
***