Chapter 41 - Who Pays for the Number

By seven the next morning, the appendix was spread across our kitchen table.
Clara sat in her high chair, attempting to push a piece of banana into the narrow opening of her cup. Evan watched me underline the same sentence for the third time.
“You’ve found something,” he said.
“I’ve found a number pretending it doesn’t have people underneath it.”
The proposed savings included reduced supervisory coverage, flexible reassignment of restricted-duty employees, and consolidation of southern-site operations into a facility operated by an outside provider.
Each line sounded efficient.
None identified who would perform the work after the savings were removed.
I took a clean sheet and divided it into three columns.
The proposed change.
The assumption supporting it.
The consequence if that assumption failed.
Beside the scheduling line, I wrote Rosa.
Then I crossed out her name.
Not because she did not matter.
Because she was not the only person affected, and I had already learned what happened when one woman became the public symbol for everyone else’s uncertainty.
Evan pushed a mug toward me.
“Are you eating?”
“Yes.”
He looked at my untouched toast.
“Interesting definition.”
I put down the pen.
For ten minutes, we ate breakfast.
Clara dropped the banana, announced something that might have been a complaint, and accepted a second piece as though the first had been an administrative failure.
At headquarters, the independent chair asked that the appendix be examined through a small operational team. Nadine would assess capacity. Alina would examine the financial assumptions. Employee relations would evaluate workforce consequences. I would coordinate the questions without turning the exercise into a personal campaign against the offer.
I agreed.
Then the chair added, “A higher price remains relevant.”
“I know.”
“We cannot dismiss a proposal because we dislike its authors.”
“I know that too.”
She studied me for a moment.
“Good. Then make the comparison strong enough to survive someone who wants the proposal to succeed.”
That was harder than collecting reasons to hate it.
It was also the right assignment.
By noon, Nadine found the first gap.
The consolidation model assumed the receiving facility could absorb nearly all southern-site volume within six weeks. Its supporting document was a capacity estimate supplied by the proposed outside operator.
There was no completed acceptance test.
No signed commitment reserving the required space.
No demonstrated staffing plan for the peak periods when our southern site already struggled.
Alina found another problem.
A recurring allowance appeared in two separate savings categories. One removed it through revised scheduling. Another removed it again through site consolidation.
“If both changes happen,” she said, “you still only stop paying the allowance once.”
I stared at the spreadsheet.
“How much?”
“Enough to affect the comparison. We need the source model before using a final figure.”
At three, employee relations supplied a list of affected job categories.
Rosa’s assignment was one of several.
So were arrangements involving an employee returning after surgery, a father whose fixed schedule aligned with a child’s medical appointments, and workers whose dependable shifts supported transportation they could actually afford.
Some arrangements could be changed appropriately after review.
The proposal treated all of them as immediately removable expense.
That difference needed to appear beside the savings.
Not in a separate human-interest section someone could skip.
At four twenty, Rosa wrote to the independent contact.
She had heard her site might close.
She wanted to know whether she should continue preparing her leave handover.
The adviser obtained permission to share the question with us.
I read it aloud in the review room.
Nobody spoke immediately.
Then Nadine said, “We need an employee update today.”
“We don’t have a decision,” a communications manager replied.
“We have the status,” I said.
The update explained that a shareholder proposal included possible consolidation, that no site decision had been approved, and that employees should continue using the existing arrangements. It identified who would answer individual questions and when the next update would be provided.
It did not promise the site would remain open forever.
It did not ask employees to remain positive.
Carrie sent it after the relevant checks.
At home, I arrived while Evan was bathing Clara.
I heard water splash and his exhausted laugh from the hallway.
For a moment, I remained outside the bathroom, holding my bag.
Then I put it down and went in.
Clara immediately handed me a wet plastic fox.
Apparently, I had been appointed to help.
Later, after she slept, Alina called.
Quaybridge had supplied a presentation responding to our questions.
The double-counted savings were described as illustrative.
The missing capacity commitment was described as commercially available.
The workforce assumptions were described as consistent with lawful operational flexibility.
I sat down.
“What did they say about the consequences?”
Alina was quiet.
“They said management could address implementation details after the transaction.”
I looked toward the stairs.
May you like
Someone wanted shareholders to approve the number first.
The people paying for it would be explained afterward.