Chapter 75 - The Question She Wouldn’t Answer

Lydia testified before I did.
I sat outside until Grace told me it was time.
That was harder than listening would have been.
Without her voice to react to, my imagination supplied one. Calm. Patient. Regretful that technical disputes had become personal.
When I entered, the room looked smaller than it had in my head.
No thunder.
No dramatic hush.
People moving papers and checking the time.
I answered the preliminary questions.
My name.
My role.
The limits of my involvement.
Then we reached AM-17.
I explained that an index describing preserved material was not a certification of every financial assertion someone might later attach to it. I explained that identifying a record did not endorse its contents.
The attorney questioning me asked whether the original index proved a particular reserve was available for distribution.
“No.”
Did it prove the reserve did not exist?
“No.”
Then what did it prove?
“That a defined set of records was identified and preserved within a stated scope.”
I saw Paige shift in the back row.
Not bored.
Listening.
The questions became sharper.
I was asked about my promotion. My family’s financial interest. My unauthorized conduct involving Graham’s vehicle.
I answered.
Yes, Dad had a claim.
Yes, I had benefited professionally after the arrest.
Yes, I had made an unauthorized decision.
No, none of that changed the language of the original preservation scope.
The attorney asked whether I considered myself a reliable judge of my own conduct.
Grace objected.
The question was narrowed.
I took a breath.
“I’m explaining the records I worked on. I’m not asking anyone to accept my character as a substitute for them.”
For a second, I heard my own voice as though someone else had spoken.
Then another page was placed before me.
A summary prepared for the prospective purchaser.
It cited AM-17 as support for a representation that no additional material schedules were expected.
“Did you make that representation?”
“No.”
“Did anyone ask your team to make it?”
“Not within the assignment I performed.”
“Could the index support that conclusion by itself?”
“No.”
The answer did not destroy anyone.
It removed one support from a structure someone had been calling complete.
That was enough work for one word.
After I stepped down, Lydia was recalled.
This time, I could remain.
She was asked whether Morrow knew Jonah’s acknowledgment was disputed when the purchase offers were prepared.
She said concerns had been raised.
She was asked whether the purchaser had been told the acknowledgment contained a qualification.
She said the relevant material had been available through advisers.
Then came the question.
“Did you instruct Simon Vale to obtain an unqualified statement?”
Lydia looked toward her counsel.
The pause lasted long enough for everyone to notice.
Her attorney requested a brief conference.
When questioning resumed, the answers became narrower.
The phrase valuation window appeared three times.
So did commercial judgment.
The judge asked to see the correspondence directly.
Nobody looked pleased.
By late afternoon, the immediate result was limited but concrete. The proposed use of the disputed acknowledgment would require further support. Claimants were to receive clarified information before any additional acceptances were treated as final under the arrangement being reviewed.
Outside, Dad stood by the steps with Mom.
He had watched the whole thing.
“How’d I do?” I asked.
He considered.
“Long.”
Paige laughed.
Then Dad put a hand on my shoulder.
“Clear.”
That evening, the family ate at a diner because nobody wanted to cook.
Mom complained that the pie crust was too thick.
Evan said that was the first reliable finding of the day.
We were still laughing when Paige’s phone lit up.
Rachel had sent a message.
Simon had delivered a box to her attorney.
Inside were clothes, two books, and Jonah’s envelope.
Paige read the next line silently.
Then she looked up.
“The marked copy isn’t in it.”
“What is?” I asked.
May you like
She swallowed.
“A receipt saying it was destroyed at Jonah’s request.”