Chapter 1 - The Smile on the Stairs

I reached the bottom of the stairs just as Grace hung her wool coat in the foyer closet. Her cheeks were flushed pink from the chilly afternoon air, and she carried a pastry box tied with red twine from the upscale bakery on Elm Street.
“Hi, Katherine!” Grace chirped, her voice as light as birdsong. “They had those almond croissants David loves, so I grabbed a half-dozen. Is Emily back from practice yet?”
I kept one hand resting casually inside my cardigan pocket, my fingertips brushing the folded edges of Stanford’s devastating letter. For fifteen years in newsrooms across Chicago and Boston, I had interviewed corrupt governors, embezzling CEOs, and predatory landlords.
Grace’s innocent expression was good. In fact, it was very good.
“She’s upstairs resting,” I said, offering a smooth, practiced smile that didn't reach my eyes. “Tough swim practice today. Lots of sprints.”
Grace tilted her head, her dark eyes darting up the staircase for a fraction of a second before returning to me. “Oh, poor thing. She pushes herself so hard. Sometimes I worry she’s taking on more than she can handle.”
The subtle jab was delivered with surgical precision, wrapped in the sweet guise of sisterly concern. Three days ago, I would have overlooked it as ordinary teenage friction.
Now, every syllable sounded like an opening statement in an indictment.
“She knows her limits,” I replied evenly, walking into the kitchen to check on the simmering onions. “How was your day, Grace? Any word from your waitlists?”
Grace set the pastry box on the marble island, her shoulders drooping in a brief, delicate show of disappointment. “Nothing yet. But honestly, I’ve accepted it. Not everyone can be a superstar like Emily.”
She sighed softly, running her fingers along the edge of the granite counter. “I just want what’s fair, you know? Hard work should count for something in the end.”
“It always does,” I said, turning the burner down to low. “Truth has a funny way of surfacing, no matter how deep someone tries to bury it.”
Grace paused, her hand stilling on the counter. A flicker of calculation crossed her features, so brief that an untrained eye would have completely missed it.
“Of course,” Grace said, recovering her bright tone with an easy nod. “I’m going to start my history essay before dinner. Let me know when David gets home.”
She turned and headed up the stairs, her footsteps light and unbothered. I stood by the stove, watching her ascend until her bedroom door clicked shut on the second floor.
My heart was beating in a cold, steady rhythm that I hadn't felt in nearly four years. The quiet homemaker who worried about lint traps and PTA bake sales had just stepped out of the room.
Katherine Reynolds was officially back on the clock.
I wiped my hands on an apron, took off the floral cotton cloth, and hung it on the pantry hook. Then I walked through the kitchen, unlocked the heavy deadbolt leading to the garage, and clicked on the fluorescent overhead lights.
The garage smelled of lawn fertilizer, cedar mulch, and damp concrete.
I walked straight to the high industrial shelving unit behind the workbench, reaching behind the dusty cans of latex paint on the top shelf.
My hands found the rectangular cardboard shoebox sealed with yellowed packing tape. I pulled it down, blowing away a fine layer of dust before carrying it over to the workbench.
Inside that box was my past: two encrypted external hard drives, an old press badge from the Chicago Tribune, my private digital voice recorder, and a small black leather notebook filled with direct phone numbers for forensic data recovery analysts, private investigators, and university ombudsmen.
I pulled out my phone and dialed a ten-digit number from memory.
May you like
The line clicked on the third ring. “Marcus Vance speaking.”
“Marcus,” I said quietly into the receiver. “It’s Katherine Reynolds. I need a digital forensics favor, and I need it yesterday.”