Chapter 56 - Mia Chose Not to Answer

Sophia tried again through someone else.
Not a dramatic message.
Not an accusation.
A photograph.
Mia at five, sitting on Marcus’s shoulders beneath a striped beach umbrella.
The note beneath it said:
Remember when we were a family before people taught you to hate me.
Mia showed Denise first.
Then she asked whether I could come.
I arrived to find her sitting on the floor beside Denise’s sofa, phone facedown.
She looked furious.
“I don’t hate her.”
“I know.”
“Then why does she keep making me prove it?”
I sat on the rug.
Denise remained nearby.
Nobody took the phone without asking.
Mia pressed her palms against her eyes.
“I miss her voice.”
The admission came out like something shameful.
I shook my head.
“You’re allowed.”
“But then she does this.”
“Yes.”
She looked at me suddenly.
“Did you ever miss Vincent when you knew he was bad for you?”
The question found its mark.
I answered carefully.
“Yes.”
“What did you do?”
“Sometimes I cried. Sometimes I got angry. Sometimes I imagined a conversation that would finally make him understand.”
“Did it help?”
“Usually not.”
She gave a short, miserable laugh.
Then she asked whether missing someone meant she should answer.
“No.”
“What if something happens to her?”
“That fear is real. It still doesn’t make every message your responsibility.”
Mia stared at the phone.
Denise suggested that any future contact be discussed with the people overseeing her arrangements rather than managed through intermediaries who kept bypassing them.
Mia nodded.
Then she did something small and enormous.
She wrote a response.
Not to send immediately.
To show her advocate.
I miss you. I don’t want messages that make me responsible for your feelings. If you want to talk to me, use the arrangement you’ve been given.
She read it aloud.
Her voice shook.
Then she put the phone away.
When we returned to the estate for dinner, Vincent noticed her eyes but did not ask her to explain at the table.
He asked whether she wanted potatoes.
She said yes.
That was the right question.
Later, she found him in the garden.
I watched from the kitchen while they spoke.
After a while, she handed him something.
The beach photograph.
When he came inside, he looked stricken.
“She asked whether remembering Marcus means she has to believe everything her mother says about him.”
“What did you tell her?”
“That her father did things I’m still trying to understand. And that loving him doesn’t require her to defend every story.”
I nodded.
“Good.”
He placed the photograph on the counter.
Marcus smiled up at his little daughter.
A dead man.
A father.
A participant in things he had questioned too late.
None of those facts erased the others.
The next day, the longer-term planning meeting for Mia took place.
Denise’s possible move remained uncertain.
Our household assessment continued.
Vincent’s legal situation limited what anyone could promise.
For the first time, Mia arrived with her own written questions.
Where would she go to school?
Who would tell her if plans changed?
Would she be allowed to keep seeing Leo?
Where would her things remain while adults decided?
The caseworker answered what she could.
The unanswered questions were recorded.
Mia watched her write them down.
I saw her shoulders lower slightly.
Afterward, she told me, “I like her better when she admits she doesn’t know.”
“So do I.”
That evening, Hannah called with a Bellwether update.
Recovered materials included an internal register linking outside inquiries to payment approvals.
Tessa’s delivery reference appeared there.
So did my old search file.
The same administrator had authorized both.
Adrian Vale.
But the register also contained a note that changed the direction of the inquiry.
Adrian had requested Bellwether’s retained photographs for a meeting last month.
Not six years ago.
May you like
Last month.
Someone had reopened the file after I returned.