Chapter 5 - The Phantom Ex

Sloan took a slow sip of something over the line, the ice clinking against glass through the receiver.
“Did Carter tell you why we broke up five years ago?” she asked quietly.
“He said you grew apart after college,” I answered, recalling Carter’s vague, wistful sighs whenever the topic came up.
“He said your career took you to North Carolina and neither of you wanted to do long-distance.”
Sloan laughed again, louder this time, filled with incredulous amusement.
“Of course he said that. God forbid Carter ever admits to being dumped.”
She cleared her throat, her voice turning sharp and deadly serious.
“We didn’t grow apart, Mara. I dumped Carter because he spent two years comparing me to his high school sweetheart, Chloe.”
The breath caught in my throat, freezing halfway down my windpipe.
“Chloe?” I repeated, the name echoing in my empty loft like a cruel joke.
“Yes. Chloe was the quiet, sweet, perfect girl who died in a car accident during their freshman year of college,” Sloan said.
“Carter took her memory and turned it into an untouchable, impossible standard that no living human could ever meet.”
I slid down against the brick wall, pulling my knees to my chest as the truth snapped into focus with blinding clarity.
“Every time I chose a paint color, Chloe would have picked a softer shade,” Sloan continued, her words mirroring my exact nightmare.
“Every time I booked a vacation, Chloe loved the mountains more. Every time Denise criticized my cooking, Carter told me Chloe made better pies.”
“He weaponized a ghost,” I whispered, tears of sudden, overwhelming relief finally spilling over my eyelashes.
I wasn't defective.
I wasn't insecure, or dramatic, or bad at choosing garlic bread, or incapable of handling a mother-in-law.
Carter Reeves didn’t love Sloan Barrett, and he hadn't loved Chloe; he loved the ghost he could wield like a knife.
“Carter doesn't want a partner, Mara,” Sloan said gently through the speaker.
“He wants an insecure, desperate girl who spends every waking second trying to earn his approval so she never notices his mediocrity.”
“Sloan... thank you,” I choked out, wiping my face with the sleeve of my oversized sweater.
“You have no idea what hearing this means to me. I thought I was losing my mind for eighteen months.”
May you like
“You didn't lose your mind, Mara,” Sloan answered with fierce warmth.
“You found your spine. And trust me, leaving that family was the best decision I ever made in my life.”