Chapter 6 - The Pawnshop Appraisal

While Barbara was being booked into the DuPage County detention center, Kelsey Vance was sitting in the waiting area of an upscale jewelry boutique on Michigan Avenue.
She was dressed in a beige maternity dress that accentuated her twenty-week bump, her designer sunglasses pushed up onto her blonde hair.
Her phone had been ringing off the hook for three hours, but she had ignored every call from unknown numbers, assuming they were persistent reporters looking for an interview about the courthouse confrontation.
Clutched tightly in her manicured hand was the platinum diamond wedding ring I had placed in her palm yesterday afternoon.
She had spent the morning convincing herself that Evan would laugh off the board meeting, buy her an even larger ring, and set up a multi-million-dollar trust for their unborn child.
Yet an uneasy, gnawing panic had driven her to this appraisal shop; she wanted to verify the diamond's value just in case she needed emergency cash while Evan was busy at the office.
The jeweler, an elderly man named Mr. Goldstein who had handled estate pieces in Chicago for forty years, walked out from the back examination room holding a black velvet tray.
He set the platinum ring down beneath the bright halogen counter lamp, looking over his half-moon reading glasses with a solemn, sympathetic expression.
“Miss Vance,” Mr. Goldstein said, folding his hands over the glass display case.
“I have completed the optical analysis and serial verification of the diamond.”
Kelsey smiled, leaning forward with confident anticipation.
“It’s a flawless four-carat cushion cut, isn't it? Evan told me he paid eighty-five thousand dollars for it at Tiffany’s when they got engaged.”
Mr. Goldstein sighed softly, shaking his head.
“The setting is genuine platinum, valued at approximately eight hundred dollars in scrap weight,” he explained gently.
“However, the center stone is a synthetic cubic zirconia, manufactured with a low-grade optical coating that has already begun to scratch around the girdle.”
Kelsey froze, the blood draining from her cheeks until she looked like a ghost.
“Synthetic?” she squeaked, her voice cracking.
“That’s impossible! Evan would never buy a fake diamond! He’s a multi-millionaire!”
“I checked the regional registration archives, Miss Vance,” Mr. Goldstein replied, sliding a yellowed appraisal sheet across the counter.
“The original Tiffany diamond was sold back to an auction house five years ago by Mr. Evan Cross for sixty-two thousand dollars in liquid cash. He had this replica set into the original band shortly afterward.”
Kelsey stared at the cheap piece of glass resting on the velvet tray, her hands beginning to tremble so violently that her purse slipped from her lap, spilling her lipstick and compact onto the floor.
Five years ago.
Evan had been replacing genuine diamonds with glass to fund his gambling debts and lavish trips long before he ever met her in that hotel bar.
Her phone buzzed violently on the glass counter.
She swiped the screen with trembling fingers, and a news alert from the Chicago Tribune flashed across the screen in bold black type:
May you like
BREAKING: Evan Cross Arrested for Multi-Million Dollar Corporate Embezzlement; All Assets and Bank Accounts Frozen by Court Order.
Kelsey collapsed back into the leather armchair, clutching her pregnant stomach as a ragged, terrified sob broke from her chest, realizing that the golden future she had stolen was nothing more than an illusion built on cheap, broken glass.