Chapter 34 - The Questions They Wanted Me to Answer

My deposition began at nine-thirty.
By nine-twenty, I had already checked the location of the restroom, the water pitcher, and the nearest window.
Eleven years in trauma nursing had taught me that preparation did not require optimism.
Ben sat beside me.
Across the table, Nolan’s attorney arranged his papers in neat stacks.
The room had no dramatic view. Just a parking garage and part of a brick building. I found that strangely reassuring.
Nothing about the space suggested that my life had been waiting for this moment.
After the formalities, the questions began.
My employment.
My qualifications.
My relationship with Derek.
How often had I helped him financially?
Had I ever expressed concern for my father?
Had I ever said families deserved support after medical treatment?
“Yes,” I answered.
The attorney looked up.
“So you supported the concept.”
“I support many things I have not agreed to manage or fund.”
He glanced down again.
Ben had warned me not to give speeches.
I folded my hands and waited.
We moved through old messages.
A birthday greeting.
A note asking whether my father had reached an appointment safely.
A message from years earlier in which I told Derek I hoped his business succeeded.
The attorney read that one slowly.
“Did you mean it?”
“Yes.”
“Would it be fair for your brother to believe you wanted to help him succeed?”
“Wanting someone to succeed is different from agreeing to participate in a particular venture.”
He tried again.
I answered again.
By eleven, I understood how exhausting it could be to defend ordinary language against someone determined to enlarge it.
Then he introduced the sale of Maple Ridge Lane.
“Your family experienced considerable distress following that transaction.”
“I’m aware they were upset.”
“You arranged the move without informing them.”
“I arranged the move of my belongings from a house I had sold.”
“You knew your brother expected to live there.”
“Yes.”
“Would you describe your conduct as intended to teach him a lesson?”
Ben shifted slightly beside me.
I thought about the woman I had been at the Marriott, silencing calls with a cup of tea in front of her.
I could deny the anger.
I could make myself sound nobler.
Instead, I answered the actual question.
“I wanted to protect my property, complete the sale, and leave. I was also angry with him.”
The attorney paused.
“Angry enough to withhold support later?”
“I did not owe support before I was angry.”
The room went still for a moment.
After lunch, we reached the false endorsement.
He asked whether I could rule out every possible conversation in which someone might have misunderstood me.
“No,” I said.
Ben remained still.
I continued.
“I can tell you I never agreed to provide the services or money attributed to me. I can identify my communications. I cannot account for every assumption someone chose to make.”
The attorney turned a page.
“Your mother admits she knowingly confirmed an agreement that did not exist.”
“Yes.”
“Your brother admits participating in draft language.”
“Yes.”
“So why hold my client responsible for relying on them?”
I looked at him.
“Your client’s own messages discuss what would happen when I refused.”
He asked another question before I could say more.
That was fine.
The message existed whether I repeated it or not.
We finished after four.
Outside, my knees felt strangely hollow.
Ben walked beside me without speaking until we reached the elevator.
“How did I do?”
“You answered the questions. You corrected inaccurate premises. You didn’t pretend to know things you couldn’t know.”
It sounded ordinary.
I needed ordinary.
At the hotel, I ordered pasta and changed into an old sweatshirt.
A message from my mother waited on my phone.
I hope today wasn’t too hard.
I read it, then set it aside.
Later, Ben called.
Nolan’s production included a revised funding schedule.
The lender’s file contained a different version.
May you like
On Nolan’s copy, my support remained conditional.
On the lender’s copy, the qualification had disappeared.