Chapter 6 - The Coffee Shop Confession

An hour after Caleb was marched out of the hospital in front of eighty whispering colleagues, my phone rang again.
It was Juliet, her voice trembling with hysterical, ragged sobs.
“Miriam... please, I need to talk to you. I’m at the bakery on High Street. Just five minutes, please. I didn't know the half of what he was doing.”
I looked across the kitchen table at my brother Evan, who shook his head in warning.
“Don't go, Miriam. It’s another trap. Let the lawyers tear them apart.”
“No,” I replied, standing up and reaching for my wool coat.
“I spent seven years letting Caleb speak for me. I’m going to hear this with my own ears.”
Twenty minutes later, I walked into the quiet bakery café.
Juliet was sitting in a secluded booth in the corner, her makeup ruined by black mascara streaks, her cream coat crumpled on the seat beside her.
She looked small, exhausted, and thoroughly humiliated.
When I sat across from her, she didn't look up immediately; she stared into her untouched tea.
“Why did you come to my house on Thanksgiving, Juliet?” I asked, keeping my voice gentle and steady.
“I need to understand what kind of woman walks through an open door with a pie to replace a wife.”
Juliet buried her face in a paper napkin, her shoulders shaking with bitter sobs.
“Caleb told me you were roommates who despised each other,” she whispered, her voice hoarse.
“He swore on his mother’s life that you had signed separation papers in August. He told me you were dating someone from the university archives and that you agreed to let him introduce me to his family so everyone could move on gracefully.”
I let out a soft, sad sigh, shaking my head.
“And you believed him? You didn't ask to see a single document?”
“He was so convincing, Miriam!” she cried, looking up with red, swollen eyes.
“He had our future mapped out. He showed me condo listings in Chicago, told me we were moving together in January, and swore his father was eager to meet me because his marriage with you had been dead for years.”
She reached into her purse and pulled out a small black leather notebook.
“Then today at the hospital... I found this in his briefcase while he was arguing with the security guards.”
She pushed the notebook across the laminate table toward me.
Inside were Caleb’s handwritten notes detailing his job transfer to Chicago, accompanied by two separate printouts of rental applications.
One was for an apartment with Juliet on Michigan Avenue.
The other was an executive bachelor studio in Lincoln Park, registered solely under Caleb’s name, dated two weeks prior.
“He wasn't moving with me,” Juliet choked out, fresh tears spilling over her eyelashes.
“He told the Chicago firm he was an unattached bachelor. He was using me to stage an exit from Columbus, and the second we reached Illinois, he was going to dump me just like he dumped you.”
I looked at the woman sitting across from me, realizing that Caleb hadn't just destroyed me; he was a serial predator of people’s trust, discarding women the moment they ceased to serve his upward mobility.
“What are you going to do now, Juliet?”
May you like
“I resigned from my public relations firm an hour ago,” Juliet said, wiping her face.
“I’m moving back to my parents' house in Pittsburgh tonight. And I gave the hospital’s forensic auditors the hotel receipts from Key West. I’m not going to prison to protect that monster.”